Powell Declares Victory While Markets Throw a Tantrum
- Brett Hall
- Dec 20, 2024
- 4 min read

Jerome Powell, the man who’s supposed to guide our economic destiny, has done it again. He stood at his podium, declared “It’s pretty clear we’ve avoided a recession,” and somehow managed to tank the markets faster than you can say “soft landing.” If Powell’s aim was to inspire confidence, well, he inspired something—panic. Let’s dive into the carnage left behind by the Fed meeting and see if we can make sense of this economic circus.
The Market's Reaction
When Powell announced his “no recession” verdict, the markets did the financial equivalent of spitting out their coffee. Here’s how it played out:
The Nasdaq: Down 2.5% immediately after Powell’s comments. By the end of the week, it had shed a cool 4.2%, with mega-cap tech stocks leading the way into the abyss.
Bitcoin: The poster child for financial rebellion dropped $2,000 in a flash, erasing nearly 7% of its value since the meeting. For a currency that’s supposed to be uncorrelated to central banks, Bitcoin sure seems to care about Jerome Powell’s feelings.
Tesla: Elon Musk’s pride and joy nosedived over 12% this week. If Tesla were a meme, it would be the one where everything is on fire, and the dog is saying, “This is fine.”
S&P 500: Down 3% post-meeting and 5% for the month. So much for the Santa Claus rally.
And if you think that’s bad, Treasury yields joined the pity party. The 10-year yield surged to 4.68%, up 11.3 basis points since the meeting, making it clear that borrowing money is about to get even more painful.
The Fed’s Messaging: Mixed Signals, Anyone?
Powell kicked things off with a victory lap, declaring that the U.S. economy had sidestepped a recession. But his tone quickly shifted when he admitted the labor market is “softer than before the pandemic” and that unemployment might “trend up a bit.” That’s Fed-speak for “things aren’t great, but let’s pretend they are.”
Powell then doubled down on the optimism, calling inflation a “technical issue.” He essentially told us that the cost of living is high because of rounding errors. Someone should explain to Jerome that families deciding whether to buy groceries or pay rent aren’t worried about his rounding logic.
Labor Market Woes: Soft Landing or Crash Landing?
Despite Powell’s pep talk, the data paints a grimmer picture:
Job Creation: At its lowest level since 2019. November added just 150,000 jobs, well below the 200,000 consensus. Not exactly a confidence booster.
Unemployment Rate: Ticking up to 3.9%, inching closer to the Fed’s “acceptable” 4.6% threshold. That’s Fed-speak for “We’re okay with things getting worse as long as it’s gradual.”
Quits Rate: Down to 2.3%, a sign that workers aren’t feeling confident enough to jump ship for better opportunities.
Powell tried to downplay the labor market’s struggles, insisting it’s just a phase. Meanwhile, Wall Street started pricing in the possibility that unemployment could spike above 5% by mid-2025. If that happens, we’re looking at layoffs, reduced spending, and—you guessed it—an actual recession.
Inflation: The “Technical Issue” That Won’t Go Away
Powell described inflation as a rounding error, but the numbers tell a different story:
Core Inflation (CPI): November’s month-over-month reading came in at 0.3%, which annualizes to 3.6%. That’s not exactly “on track,” Jerome.
Headline Inflation (CPI): While lower at 3%, it’s still stubbornly above the Fed’s 2% target.
Housing Costs: A significant contributor to inflation, rose another 0.4% in November. Powell’s “technical issue” feels more like a technical knockout for renters.
The Fed’s response? Fewer rate cuts in 2025. Powell slashed expectations from four cuts to two, signaling that the fight against inflation isn’t over.
The Yield Curve: An Uninverted Disaster
Remember when everyone panicked about the inverted yield curve? Well, it’s no longer inverted, but that’s not good news. The 10-year and 2-year yields have “uninverted” because long-term rates are rising faster than Powell can deliver his speeches. The 10-year Treasury yield is now hovering near 4.7%, while the 2-year sits at 4.58%. This is the market’s way of saying, “We don’t believe your inflation narrative, Jerome.”
The Fed’s Flip-Flopping Forecasts
Adding to the confusion, Powell announced that the Fed would start considering tariffs in its inflation projections. This is a sharp reversal from their previous stance of ignoring tariffs until they actually took effect. Flip-flopping faster than a fish out of water, Powell left markets wondering what else the Fed might change its mind about next.
GDP: The Calm Before the Storm?
The one bright spot in Powell’s narrative was GDP growth. The Atlanta Fed projects Q4 GDP at 3.2%, a solid number by any measure. But let’s not forget 2007, when GDP growth was robust right before the Great Recession. High GDP doesn’t mean we’re out of the woods—it just means we’re spending money like it’s going out of style.
Investor Sentiment: Doom and Gloom
Investor surveys show growing pessimism:
AAII Sentiment Survey: Bullish sentiment dropped to 27%, while bearish sentiment climbed to 44%, the highest in six months.
VIX Index: The so-called “fear gauge” jumped 18% post-meeting, reflecting heightened market anxiety.
Even Powell’s attempt to reassure investors fell flat. His declaration that the economy is “fine” was about as convincing as a used car salesman promising, “This one’s a gem!”
What’s Next?
Powell’s mixed messaging has left markets dazed and confused. On one hand, he’s celebrating a recession-free economy. On the other, he’s warning about a weakening labor market and stubborn inflation. It’s like Powell is playing a game of economic Twister, and we’re all losing.
If the Fed’s goal was to calm the markets, they failed spectacularly. Stocks are down, yields are up, and Bitcoin looks like it needs a hug. At this rate, Powell might need to add “therapist” to his job description.
So, what should you do? Well, if you’re a trader, it’s going to be a bumpy ride. If you’re a long-term investor, maybe avoid checking your portfolio for a while. And if you’re Jerome Powell, maybe consider a communications coach. The markets could use a little clarity, Jerome.
Comments